Category Archive: Medicine

September 21, 2011

Deschooling Society

Category: Education,Medicine,Miscellaneous :: Link :: Print

Ivan Illich’s Deschooling Society is, in many ways, a disappointing book.  The problem is not just that it’s outdated.  The problem is that the flashes of insight that impressed me at the beginning of the book were reduced to a trickle midway through and that, while I appreciated a lot of Illich’s critique of compulsory government schooling, his own suggestions for a “deschooled” society struck me as quixotic and utopian, bordering on ludicrous.

That said, there was stuff I appreciated, stuff that (even if you don’t agree with it) makes you say “Huh!  I need to think about that some more,” beginning with the opening paragraph:

Many students, especially those who are poor, intuitively know what the schools do for them.  They school them to confuse process and substance.  Once these become blurred, a new logic is assumed: the more treatment there is, the better are the results; or, escalation leads to success.  The pupil is thereby “schooled” to confuse teaching with learning, grade advancement with education, a diploma with competence, and fluency with the ability to say something new.  His imagination is “schooled” to accept service in place of value.  Medical treatment is mistaken for health care, social work for the improvement of community life, police protection for safety, military poise for national security, the rat race for productive work.  Health, learning, dignity, independence, and creative endeavor are defined as little more than the performance of the institutions which claim to serve these ends, and their improvement is made to depend on allocating more resources to the management of hospitals, schools, and other agencies in question (1).

[ low price cialis | cialis canadian pharmacy | how much is viagra | buy viagra in uk | map of france with cialis | discount phentermine viagra | get viagra fast | cialis transdermal | cialis 20 mg | viagra fast | recreational viagra use | buying viagra | cheapest generic viagra | how to get viagra no prescription | viagra buy in uk online | find viagra online | buy inurl viagra viagra | levitra vs viagra | cialis fast delivery usa | cialis online without prescription | viagra sales u.k | koluba.up2.co.il order viagra | over the counter viagra | viagra the little blue pill | viagra en gel | viagra canada | cheapest viagra anywhere | discount skocz.pl viagra | who sells generic viagra | viagra usage | overnight delivery cialis | buying generic cialis | which is better viagra or cialis | women use viagra | popularity of viagra | buy levitra online viagra | when did viagra come out | cialis | what is cialis professional | pfizer viagra | purchase cialis overnight delivery | citrate salt of sildenafil | performance anxiety viagra | viagra purchase by phone | cialis cheap | stores that sell viagra | viagra china | no prescription viagra | viagra cost | buy cialis without a prescription | sildenafil oral jelly | generic viagra online | when was viagra discovered | viagra and sexual performance ]

Posted by John Barach @ 1:08 pm | Discuss (1)
January 18, 2008

Medical Myths

Category: Medicine :: Link :: Print

Several years ago, I blogged about the myth that says that we ought to drink the equivalent of eight glasses of water a day.  Now here is an article on that myth and a bunch more.  (HT: Pete Scholtens)

[ buy viagra in england | original brand cialis | cialis generic | herbal viagra reviews | professional cialis online | viagra expiration date | viagra next day delivery | when did viagra come out | viagra results | cialis medication | viagra for women | cheap viagra order online | buy online pharmacy viagra | what is better than viagra | cheapest prices on viagra | does generic viagra work | viagra without prescription | buy viagra in great britain | pizer india viagra side effects | where can i buy illegal viagra | viagra canadian scam | drink alcohol with viagra | cheep viagra | free viagra | viagra cheap prescription | viagra online pharmacy usa | purchase viagra online | herbal alternative to viagra | viagra high blood pressure | viagra price germany | viagra order cheap | buy viagra uk | cialis samples | sildenafil citrate warnings | order viagra online | pfizer viagra | viagra uit india | how much is cialis in canada | viagra in india | viagra soft generic | brand viagra over the net | viagra pill | buy viagra cheap | alternative female viagra | how long will viagra last | cialis angioplasty | veega | buy cialis without a prescription | buy cialis | viagra online without a prescription | buy cheap viagra | which is better viagra cialis | viagra 50 mg | natural viagra ]

Posted by John Barach @ 1:51 pm | Discuss (2)
April 7, 2006

Hippocratic Oath

Category: Medicine :: Link :: Print

While I drove from Grande Prairie to Medford, I listened to the first volume of the Mars Hill Audio Journal. The volume included an interview with Nigel M. DeS. Cameron about his (then) recent book, The New Medicine: Life and Death After Hippocrates.

I appreciate Cameron’s call for Christian doctors and nurses to form their own alternative subculture, that is, to maintain their own standards, grounded on God’s word, in spite of the trends in the medical culture around. I recall, though I haven’t read the book, that Jakob van Bruggen in Het leven is de moeite waard argues that, in a time when many opt for euthanasia and many in the medical community are starting to think that euthanasia is a good option, we need Christian nurses who are committed to providing paliative care for those who are dying slowly. Cameron’s point sounds similar.

But the jarring note in the interview was Cameron’s recommendation of the Hippocratic Oath. I grant that the content of the oath may be good, but surely Christians can do something better.

Cameron wants to have that oath, which was originally produced in a pagan society, used as common ground between modern pagans and Christians. “Look,” we Christians can say. “Here is a pagan oath with which we can agree and with which you pagans ought to agree.”

Never mind that modern day unbelievers, with a few exceptions, are hardly “pagans,” comparable in belief to guys like Hippocrates. If Christians doctors are going to form their own subculture and follow their own biblical standards, then why should they base what they’re doing on Hippocrates? Why should they even bother trying to make themselves sound acceptable by an appeal to an ancient pagan medical oath?

What about “marketing” a Christian approach to the rest of the world so that others follow suit? It seems to me that the early church did just fine at such “marketing” in the midst of ancient pagan culture when the early Christians doctored, nursed, and cared for the pagans, not according to pagan standards, but according to biblical ones.

[ canada pharmacy viagra pfizer | indian sildenafil citrate | viagra free trial | indian sildenafil citrate | cialis professional 20 mg | how strong is 5 mg of cialis | viagra cialis levitra | prescription cialis | usa generic viagra | viagra next day delivery | active ingredient in viagra | low cost viagra | cialis online canada | cialis buy overnight | sildenafil citrate warnings | herbal viagra welnet4u.de wf | viagra clone | viagra no prescription | buying cialis online | discount canadian cialis | best price viagra | viagra without prescription | original viagra | sildenafil citrate warnings | original viagra | pfizer viagra 50mg | viagra side effects | canadian pharmacy viagra | viagra patent | viagra buy now | cialis kanada | buy viagra alternative | how quick does a cialis work | cialis dosage | popularity of viagra | fun with viagra | buy discount viagra | order viagra prescription | buy low price viagra | purchase cialis next day delivery | can young men take viagra | long term effects of viagra | picture viagra pill | cheapest viagra | real viagra | viagra buy viagra | cheap robert.up2.co.il viagra | cheap viagra online | pink viagra | active ingredient in viagra | cheap viagra | buy viagra alternative | generic viagra canadian | viagra mexico ]

Posted by John Barach @ 5:03 pm | Discuss (0)
October 11, 2002

Only in the Dark

Category: Medicine,Miscellaneous :: Link :: Print

John van Popta, my friend, colleague, and neighbour, has just informed me that he has a webpage. John is the minister of the Canadian Reformed Church in Coaldale, just a few miles east of Lethbridge. His page includes links to some of his articles and sermons (including an interesting series of four sermons on the parable of the prodigal son), but I’d especially encourage you to read his journal of his son’s battle with leukemia.

[ no prescription viagra | h h order viagra | how much is viagra from canada | buy cheap viagra online uk | how to buy viagra | canada meds viagra | viagra mexico | viagra without prescription | best prices on viagra | wholesale generic viagra in canada | 50 mg cialis | generic viagra free shipping | cheep viagra | viagra cartoons | generic viagra on line cheap | buy cialis online uk | real viagra without prescription | mail order for viagra tablets | how does viagra work | suppliers of viagra in uk | pfizer viagra 50mg | herbal viagra uk | buy levitra online viagra | age of viagra users | cheap less viagra | pfizer viagra | should i chew cialis | buy viagra on line | recreational viagra use | which is better viagra cialis | next day delivery cialis | viagra prescription | generic viagra india | buy cheap purchase uk viagra | discount canadian cialis | viagra retail discount | bruising on cialis | pizer india viagra side effects | map of france with cialis | female version viagra | viagra overnight delivery | cialisis in canada | buy viagra cheap | pfizer female viagra | how to buy viagra | cialis sales | ordering viagra overnight delivery | generic cialis | adviser finance order viagra | viagra premature | canada viagra | cialis soft | death by viagra | viagra buy now ]

Posted by John Barach @ 5:40 pm | Discuss (0)