February 21, 2014

How Would He Know?

Category: History,Theology - Liturgical :: Permalink

The longer I think about Beza’s position expressed at the Colloquy of Montbéliard, the more puzzling it becomes.  Beza “affirmed that many thousands of baptized children are never regenerated, but perish eternally.”  But … how would he know?

These aren’t people who were baptized as children and then grew up and apostatized.  Andreae would have granted that apostates perish and wouldn’t have been at all shocked that Beza affirmed that they did.  No, Beza must be speaking of children who die in infancy or at least in early youth, so that we cannot say of these children “They were clearly unbelievers.”  They were baptized; they did not apostatize (at least, that we know of!); and yet Beza is sure that thousands of them perish.

I’ve wracked my brain trying to think of reasons why Beza would assert such a thing, but I haven’t been able to come up with anything really plausible.  Did Beza perhaps think that any child who is baptized but who has ungodly parents is bound to perish in spite of his baptism?  Would Beza include in that number any child baptized in a Roman Catholic church, which Beza would likely regard as a false and apostate church.  Is that the reasoning behind Beza’s strong — and, to Andreae, shocking — affirmation?  If so, isn’t this close to Donatism, where the efficacy of the sacrament is thought to depend on the godliness of the one administering it?  I find it hard to believe that Beza would hold such a view.

Or is Beza reasoning backwards from the fact that many thousands who are baptized do end up apostate and perish to the idea that there must be many thousands of children who are baptized but who also perish?  Or …?

I really have no idea what could have prompted his claim.  Anyone out there have a suggestion?

[ viagra indigestion as a side effect | viagra gel | generic viagra mexico | china viagra | viagra generic brand | viagra stores | indian viagra | generic viagra soft tabs | viagra from india | viagra prescription label | keyword order viagra | effects of viagra | pfizer viagra 50 mg online | generic viagra lowest prices | buying viagra online | cheap viagra 50mg | cialis samples in canada | alternative drug new viagra | online pharmacy cialis | herbal viagra reviews | how much is cialis in canada | pharmacie canadian viagra | buy viagra china | viagra prescription | how much does cialis cost | free herbal viagra samples | viagra canda | mexico pharmacy cialis | canada viagra generic | advice viagra | original viagra | vigor 2000 | buying cialis soft tabs 100 mg | bruising on cialis | generic viagra usa | buy inurl viagra viagra | buy viagra online cheap | female viagra cream | women use viagra | viagra how it works | viagra report | mexican viagra | viagra alternative and woman | buy viagra on the internet | viagra soft tabs 100 mg | pfizer soft viagra | buy real cialis | viagra online store | buy pfizer viagra in canada | original brand cialis | veega | viagra store in canada | viagra 50 mg tablets | free trial of viagra ]

Posted by John Barach @ 1:29 pm | Discuss (0)

Leave a Reply